E-LEVY…*HOW DID WE GET HERE, WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE? * Stage by stage analysis (1) 

Date

Story: By Richmond Keelson & Atta Kwaku Boadi 

The Today newspaper, in the national interest is beginning a series of write ups to run readers through all stages of the introduction and implementation of the one call that is still setting the country on the edge.  The paper has thought it prudent to remind ourselves of the issues involved in order to help commentators and the citizenry alike to make informed inputs about the way forward. Our aim is to inform and educate the public about the E-Levy with the view to shaping and deepening national conversation on the subject.

So what’s “E-Levy”? On 17th November 2021, the Minister for Finance, Ken Ofori-Atta announced during the presentation of the 2022 Budget Statement and Economic Policy of Government to the Parliament of Ghana, the introduction of an “Electronic Transaction Levy” or “E-Levy” of 1.75 percent on electronic transactions above GHs 100 (US$16) per day to take effect from 1st February 2022.

According to the Minister, the levy was to be applied to “mobile money payments, bank transfers, merchant payments, and inward remittances (MoF 2022 Budget Highlights). All charges will be borne by the sender, except in the case of inward remittances where the charge will be borne by the recipient.” In March 2022, Ghana’s Parliament approved the bill with 1.50 percent taxation on electronic money transfers, but not without heated resistances including all the enthralling parliamentary procedural precedents set before the final approval of the levy.

What transactions fall under the E-Levy?
The Electronic Transaction Levy Bill clearly defines the mode of e-levy transaction: “Transfers done on the same mobile money network – For example sending money from your MTN Momo wallet to another person’s MTN Momo wallet. Transfers from one mobile money network to a recipient on another network – For example, sending money from your MTN Momo wallet to another person’s Vodafone Cash wallet. Transfers from bank accounts to mobile money accounts: For example, Kofi transfers money from his Fidelity bank account to Ama’s MTN mobile money wallet.

Transfers from mobile money accounts to bank accounts: For example, Esi transfers money from her Vodafone Cash money wallet to Yaw’s Fidelity bank account. Bank transfers (both Intra-Bank and Inter-Bank) on a digital platform or application which originate from a bank account belonging to an individual. NB: Daily threshold of Ghs 20,000.00 i.e. the tax will only be applied when the cumulative amount in a day exceeds Ghs 20,000.00.”

What transactions are NOT covered by the E-levy or are exempted?
“The following transfers,” according to the bill “are excluded from the levy: Cumulative transfers of GHS 100 per day made by the same person: Everyone has a daily tax-free threshold (limit) of GHS 100 – that is every person will be able to send up to GHS100 a day without the payment of the levy; Transfer between accounts owned by the same person: if you are sending money to your own account (i.e., of the same person) then you will not be charged the E-Levy.  A transfer from Kojo’s AirtelTigo wallet to his MTN wallet or from his CBG bank account to his GCB bank account or from his Fidelity bank account to his own Fidelity bank account or from his savings account to his current or investment account, will not attract the levy.”
Transfers for the payment of taxes, fees, and charges: “Any payment of taxes fees or charges made to an MDA or MMDA using the Ghana gov. platform or other designated method, do not attract the levy. Electronic Clearing of Cheques: Clearing of cheques by the banks and specialized deposit taking institutions such as the savings and loans companies etc. are excluded. By extension, SWIFT, ACH and GIS transfers are all exempted. Specified merchant payments: Payments made to commercial establishments through a payment service (mobile money, bank application, Fintech etc.) to a person registered with the Ghana Revenue Authority for the purposes of income tax or value- added tax is excluded. This applies to both online and physical sales.”

Transfers between principal, agent, and master-agent accounts: To avoid charging the levy multiple times, transfers that pass through multiple service providers before they get to the actual recipient do not attract the levy. Deposits and withdrawals made at Agent point will not attract any e-levy. The following transfers are also excluded/exempted from the levy: 1. Loan Disbursement from Licensed Entity 2. Loan Repayment to Licensed Entity 3. Transfers from either Account Holder to Joint Accounts 4. Transfers from Trustees to In-Trust-For (ITF) Account 5. Transfers to Escrow Accounts on Instant Pay 6. Airtime Top-Up, Data Bundle, Utility Bills 7. ATM Withdrawals

The necessity of the E-Levy: In his financial 2022 fiscal statement to Parliament, the Finance Minister alluded to why the E-Levy was so crucial to save Ghana’s economy. According to the Finance Minister, “the country’s total digital transactions for 2020 were estimated to be over GH¢500 billion (about US$81 billion) compared to GH¢78 billion (US$12.5 billion) in 2016. As a result, Government is projecting to rake in tax revenue of about GH¢6.96 billion (US$1.1 billion) in 2022, and about GH¢26.90 billion (US$4.5 billion) from 2023 to 2025 after the implementation of the electronic transaction levy to help widen the tax net and rope in the informal sector (PwC 2022 Budget Digest).

Public, stakeholder reactions to E-Levy: The Finance Minister’s presentation led to different and varied reactions from Ghanaians and industry stakeholders. There was also the intense and belligerent divide on the subject in Parliament. As usual, the majority led the approval chorus with the minority vehemently opposing it. While some industry players supported the e-levy tax introduction, as a way to increase public revenues, others criticized such and its negative impact on digital payments.  There have been concerns about the potential negative impact on government’s own digitalization agenda.

Some analysts argued that with “Ghana’s GDP contribution, led by the Services sector, accounting for an average share of 51.9 percent, first half of 2021 with the majority coming from the Information and Communication sub-sector, it thus makes a compelling case for Government to review that sector in its bid to generate more revenue.” In a counter view however, others opined that “government needs to explore multiple sources of tax revenue than to target a big source of its revenue from taxing electronic transactions.”

Why the E-Levy opposition by analysts, political parties & others: The main worry of these stakeholders is that it’s the users of digital payments that will bear the higher costs. This is captured in what they described as potential e-levy effects on “Peer to Peer” (P2P) transfers. They argue that “As of 2021, P2P transfers remain the highest transactions on mobile money platforms in Ghana and cost on average one percent per transaction (both for transfers and withdrawals) capped at GHs 10,000 (US$1,666).

The e-levy foresees an additional 1.75 percent tax on the transaction value that will result in total transaction cost of 2.75 percent on transactions above GHs 100, with no upper limit determined yet. The tax will be applied to the sender when they initiate the transfer.”

Again “Initial reactions after the announcement of the e-levy led to some panic withdrawals by mobile money customers, an indication that the e-levy can cause a reduction in the values and volumes of transactions resulting in an increase in the use of cash. Mobile money boasts of 441,000 active agents in the country who have also registered their displeasure due to the potential loss of income.”

Potential effects on merchant payments: They also argue of potential e-levy effects on merchant payments thus: “Merchant payments offer customers the opportunity to pay for products and services through mobile money. Point of Sale (POS), Quick Response (QR) Codes, rather than cash. In the case of MTN, MoMo Pay is gaining popularity gradually with its reduced transaction fee for the sender of 0.2 percent compared to the P2P transfer fee of one percent. Merchants have a five or six-digit code that customers can use to pay in place of a mobile number and are not charged to move money from their wallet to bank account.”

They continue: “Point of Sale terminals offer clients a safer and easier way to pay for goods and services using Visa and MasterCard credit or debit card from any part of the world in either cedi or foreign currency. New models of POS accept mobile money wallet payments. Currently, merchant POS commission ranges from Min 2 percent – 4 percent paid by the merchant and will be required to pay e-levy tax on their transactions. An additional levy on top of merchant fees would curtail the adoption of digital payments by informal MSMEs who tend to avoid transacting via digital payments because of merchant fees that eat into their already thin margins.”

Potential effects on bank transfers: Another area of concern is the “Bank to bank, transfer and transfer from bank to mobile money and vice versa, will also be taxed except transfers between own accounts which will not be charged. Banks still process small to large value transactions such as salary payments, P2P, B2B, B2G payments and charge various fees depending on the type of transactions through various channels including the branch, mobile banking, internet banking, ATMs. E-levy can result in lower transaction values and volumes, make banking expensive and reduce usage of financial products and services.”

Potential effects on inward remittances: Analysts believe, “remittance is a significant source of external financing and a major contributor to national income. Many Ghanaian families depend on remittances from relations living abroad to cater for various expenses including education, health, rent, housekeeping, and utilities. Ghanaians in the diaspora also send money home to fund the construction of residential and/or commercial buildings. Remittances therefore contribute to the economic well-being of Ghanaians (Bank of Ghana. Guidelines for inward remittance services by payment service providers. Feb 2021).” 

They recall “In the recent past, remittances were sent mostly using informal channels given the prohibitive costs and difficult accessibility of formal channels; however new innovative channels have emerged and have given the opportunity to access international remittances in an easier, more efficient termination to wallet. Users can easily receive remittances from abroad in their wallet (at a transaction fee) and enjoy the financial services linked to the wallet, such as savings plan or insurance. Taxing the recipient of remittance inflow could result in double charges for remittances funds that terminate straight into mobile money wallets. For such clients, an e-levy fee will be charged when they receive their remittance into their wallet”.
(In our next article Wednesday, we shall look at the intriguing debates that preceded the passage of the e-levy in Ghana and e-levy experiences in other countries)

23 thoughts on “E-LEVY…*HOW DID WE GET HERE, WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE? * Stage by stage analysis (1) ”

  1. sarang777 says:

    I am actually grateful to the owner of this site who has shared
    this fantastic article at at this time.

  2. Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article.
    I will make sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful info.
    Thanks for the post. I will definitely comeback.

  3. I read this article completely concerning the resemblance of most up-to-date and earlier technologies, it’s amazing article.

  4. We will teach you how to earn $ 7000 per hour.
    Why? We will profit from your profit.https://go.binaryoption.ae/FmUKhe

  5. buy provigil pill buymodafinilex.shop buy provigil pill

  6. موهات هم رنگش فرق داره با همه جایی که
    تو نیستی نقطه ی ضعفمه یه نگات می ارزه به هرکی دارم هی بشینی رو به
    روم ببینمت کیف کنم هی دله گیر توئه چقدره خوشگله رنگ چشمات خرابم کرده جوری بهم ریخته
    مثل زلزله دله گیر توئه چقدره
    خوشگله رنگ چشمات خرابم کرده جوری بهم ریخته مثل زلزله بیا تا غوغا
    کنیم زمین بله بیا تا بدخواهامون بیوفتن به لرزه همه عاشق میشن
    اما مث ما نه ما دوتاییامون به یه
    دنیا می ارزه دله گیر توئه چقدره خوشگله رنگ چشمات
    خرابم کرده جوری بهم ریخته مثل زلزله دله گیر توئه چقدره خوشگله رنگ چشمات خرابم کرده جوری بهم ریخته مثل زلزله

  7. ibc9 daftar says:

    Great site. Lots of helpful information here. I’m sending it to some friends ans also
    sharing in delicious. And of course, thank
    you to your effort!

  8. قدم میزنم توی شهری که ما یه روزایی با
    هم قدم میزدیم یه جاهایی اونقد عاشق شدیم
    زمین و زمانو بهم میزدیم همه خوبی هارو یه جا داشتی و
    با تو انگاری هیچی مشکل
    نبود به جز صورت پاک و خندون
    تو دیگه هیچ جا ماهی کامل نبود میخوام عزیزت شم من سر به راهت شم بهم
    نگاه کنی محو نگاهت شم دیر اومدم اما موندیم این بار
    دستای خالیمو به روی من نیار میخوام عزیزت
    شم من سر به راهت شم بهم نگاه کنی محو نگاهت شم دیر اومدم اما موندیم این بار دستای خالیمو به روی من نیار
    با هر دوست دارم از آدما چقد راحت
    دلم رفت هوایی شدم چقد دور این آدما گشتم و تو موندی صبورانه پای
    خودم کنار منی دستمو ول نکن یه دریای آبی رو واسم بساز بغل کن بغل
    کن منو خالقم یه عید حسابی رو واسم بساز میخوام عزیزت شم من
    سر به راهت شم بهم نگاه کنی محو نگاهت شم دیر اومدم اما موندیم این
    بار دستای خالیمو به روی من نیار میخوام عزیزت شم من سر به راهت شم بهم نگاه کنی محو نگاهت شم دیر اومدم اما موندیم این بار دستای خالیمو به روی من نیار

  9. مگه غیر دلبری کار دیگم بلدی آخه من فدات بشم بازم که این عطرو زدی بازم یه تیکه ماه شدی با این گلای
    پیرهنت همه جوره دل میبری حتی با اون خندیدنت چه چشمای قشنگی داری دختر تو هم یاری و
    هم دلداری دختر نرو بیرون
    بهم میریزه کوچه بشین خونه مگه بیکاری دختر خدا هرکاری میتونسته کرده تو یه شاهکار بی تکراری دختر نرو بیرون بهم میریزه کوچه بشین خونه مگه بیکاری دختر بشین
    خونه مگه بیکاری دختر … نمیدونی
    چقدر خوبی هنوز خودت نفهمیدی چقدر حالم باهات خوبه تو بوی زندگی میدی حق
    داری از دست کارام بریدی بریدی میگی دیوونه مث من ندیدی ندیدی تازه کجاشو دیدی …
    چه چشمای قشنگی داری دختر تو هم یاری و هم دلداری دختر نرو بیرون بهم میریزه کوچه بشین خونه مگه بیکاری دختر خدا هرکاری میتونسته کرده تو یه
    شاهکار بی تکراری دختر نرو بیرون بهم
    میریزه کوچه بشین خونه مگه بیکاری دختر

  10. generic modafinil 100mg Modafinil buy online generic modafinil 100mg

  11. Website says:

    Keep this going please, great job!

  12. login bp77 says:

    hello!,I really like your writing so a lot! proportion we be in contact extra about your article on AOL?
    I need a specialist on this space to resolve my problem.
    Maybe that’s you! Looking ahead to look you.

  13. Hiya very cool website!! Guy .. Excellent .. Amazing ..

    I will bookmark your web site and take the feeds also?
    I’m satisfied to search out a lot of useful
    info here in the put up, we want develop extra strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing.
    . . . . .

  14. ترک خود ارضایی از نظر علمی کاملا ممکن است.

    بخش زیادی از ترک اعتیاد به این عمل مانند هرگونه اعتیاد دیگری جنبه های
    روحی و روانی زیادی دارد. بنابر این نیاز است که با تمام اراده خود تصمیم به ترک گرفته باشید و از شکست
    هراسی نداشته باشید. در ادامه راه هایی
    برای ترک خود ارضایی که از نظر علمی ثابت شده اند را بازگو می کنیم.

    ورزش کنید
    ورزش انرژی مازاد شما را کاهش می دهد.
    ورزش علاوه بر آن شادابی و نشاط نیز با خود به ارمغان می
    آورد. ورزش هایی مثل دوییدن و
    شنا می توانند باعث ترشح اندورفین
    در بدن می شود. اندورفین هورمون شادی و نشاط در بدن است.
    همچنین ورزش هایی مانند یوگا می تواند
    آرامش و اضطراب ناشی از ترک خود ارضایی را به
    طور چشمگیری کاهش دهد و موجب آرامش هرچه بیشتر گردد.

    تغذیه سالم
    تغذیه سالم با میوه و سبزیجات کافی می تواند همیشه
    سطح انرژی شما را در سطحی
    متعادل نگه دارد و احساس خستگی و کسلی را از افراد دور نماید.
    احساس سرزندگی و نشاط می تواند افراد را از کارهایی مانند خود ارضایی که که به بدن
    آسیب وارد می کند منع نماید.

    خواب کافی
    کم خوابی با خود بی هدفی و کسالت به دنبال خواهد آورد.
    نداشتن خواب کافی به مرور افراد را دچار افسردگی می کند.
    تنظیم عادت خواب و همچنین خواب کافی به میزان
    8 ساعت در روز می تواند احساس افسردگی را
    از افراد دور می کند.

    حمام آب سرد
    حمام آب سرد در زمانی که وسوسه های
    خود ارضایی به سراغ افراد می
    آید می تواند معجزه کند. این روش به خوبی می تواند جلوی هر تکرار
    عمل خود ارضای را بگیرد.

    تنها نباشید
    معمولا خودارضایی و وسوسه های
    آن زمان به سراغ افراد می آید که تنها هستند.
    به همین دلیل توصیه می شود برای ترک خود ارضایی بهتر است خود
    را در موقعیت هایی قرار دهید که تنها نباشید.

    از تماشای فیلم ها و عکس های مستهجن دوری
    کنید
    فیلم ها و عکس های مستهجن می توانند یک عامل مهم در شروع
    وسوسه برای خود ارضایی باشد. ترک خود ارضایی زمانی ممکن می شود که افراد عامل محرک وسوسه ها را پاک کنند.
    فیلم های پورن و عکس های مربوط به صحنه های سکسی به طور یقین یکی از همین
    عوامل محرک است که افراد به راحتی می توانند از دیدن آن صرف نظر
    کنند.( اختلال تماشاگری جنسی)

    از یک مشاور کمک بگیرید

  15. بروس وین در اوایل فیلم بتمن (The Batman) می خواهد به ما بگوید که ترس
    یک ابزار است. او در این مورد صحبت می‌ کند که
    چگونه می ‌توان از حضور
    بتمن برای ترساندن افراد بد استفاده کرد، اما ممکن است مت ریوز (نویسنده/کارگردان)،
    این موضوع را به خاطر رویکرد خود برای راه‌اندازی مجدد ابرقهرمان معروف مورد توجه
    قرار دهد. این فیلم، ترسناک ترین بتمن است.
    درست از صحنه آغازین خشونت آمیز، پیام واضح
    است: این کاپیتان صلیبی مادر شما
    نیست. این فیلم، یک فیلم هیجان‌انگیز
    روان‌شناختی، خشم‌ آلود و مهیج با دوز سنگینی از صحنه های جنایی است و باور کنید
    یا نه، ریوز کاملاً هنری این
    صحنه ها را اجرا می‌ کند و به شاهکاری خیلی زیبا دست می‌یابد.

    بتمن سر جای خود ایستاده است، اما همچنان مملو از ارجاعات سینمایی است.
    اکثر فیلم های قبلی بتمن لایو اکشن است.
    رئالیسم سنگدل موجود در این
    فیلم بیشتر شبیه به فیلم سه گانه کریستوفر نولان است، اما این
    یک برداشت سینمایی تازه و جسورانه از شوالیه تاریکی (Dark Knight) است.

    نقد فیلم بتمن The Batman
    نقد فیلم بتمن The Batman
    در هر صورت، ماهیت پایه این
    فیلم خیلی شبیه به جوکر 2019 است.
    اما تفاوت اینجاست که تریلر خواکین فینیکس واقعاً نیازی به نام
    شخصیت شرور نداشت تا داستان مردی فقیر را که توسط جامعه فراموش شده است
    را روایت کند. از سوی دیگر، بتمن،
    هنوز هم به طرز شگفت‌آوری وفادار داستان بتمن
    است. این داستان از داستان‌ه ای مختلفی از کمیک‌ها به شیوه‌ای متهورانه و در عین حال محترمانه میکس می ‌کند، در
    حالی که همه اینها با آنچه تا به اینجا
    در صفحه بزرگ سینما دیده‌ایم خیلی متفاوت است.

    فقط به یک دلیل منشأ این داستان بتمن نیست.
    ریوز می‌داند که ما می ‌دانیم توماس و
    مارتا وین مرده‌اند و به درستی فرض
    می ‌کند که دیگر نیازی به تیراندازی به آنها نداریم.
    در عوض، ما مستقیماً وارد شراکت بتمن و کارآگاهی بتمن و جیم گوردون شده ایم.
    این موضوع آنقدر در داستان بروس وین اتفاق
    می ‌افتد که صحنه‌هایی را که قبلاً میلیون‌ ها بار دیده‌ایم بازخوانی نمی‌ کند، در واقع او هنوز باید کارهای زیادی انجام دهد تا اینکه ابرقهرمان تقریباً بی‌عیب و نقصی خلق
    کند. ما آغاز را نمی بینیم، اما شاهد پیشرفت
    های زیادی هستیم و همچنین برخی از
    فراخوان های هوشمندانه و اضافه شده به تاریخچه چندین
    خانواده گاتهام را می‌ بینیم.

  16. sv 388 says:

    You’re so cool! I do not think I’ve read through anything like this before.
    So great to find somebody with some original thoughts
    on this topic. Really.. thanks for starting this up.
    This web site is something that is required on the internet,
    someone with a bit of originality!

  17. อย่าห้าวให้มากไอ้เด็กเหี้ย

  18. daftar ibc9 says:

    Hmm it appears like your site ate my first comment (it was super long) so I guess I’ll just sum
    it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog.
    I as well am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to everything.
    Do you have any helpful hints for rookie blog writers?
    I’d definitely appreciate it.

  19. kucoin says:

    Everyone loves it when folks get together and share thoughts.
    Great site, stick with it!

  20. A fascinating discussion is worth comment. I do believe that you
    should publish more on this subject matter, it might not be
    a taboo subject but usually people do not discuss these topics.
    To the next! Kind regards!!

  21. binance id says:

    Hi, this weekend is good designed for me, because this
    point in time i am reading this enormous educational paragraph here at my home.

  22. Thanks in favor of sharing such a good thinking, paragraph is fastidious,
    thats why i have read it completely

  23. Click here says:

    I am truly thankful to the holder of this site who has shared this fantastic paragraph
    at here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More
articles